Gluten Free Jelly Vegetarian

Papaya Jelly Recipe Without Commercial Pectin

This website contains affiliate links. Any purchases through affiliate links will provide me with the income necessary to keep this site available at no extra cost to you. Please see Privacy Policy page for more information.
24Bite Recipe: Papaya Jelly Without Commercial Pectin

When I was growing up, we had papaya and mango trees growing near our apartment in Hawaii. We had guava trees with passion fruit vines entwined on them and even the stray pineapple, eaten warm, right off the plant.

When I went shopping the other day, there were some papayas. They weren’t Hawaiian papayas, though. They were HUGE papayas. I wanted to give them a try, especially because I like Christian to try as many different fruits and vegetables as possible.

24Bite Recipe: Papaya Jelly Without Commercial Pectin (photo credit: Sommai Larkjit via 123RF)

When I cut up this papaya, I ended up with two entire quarts of chunks. Christian liked it but wasn’t overly thrilled with it so I did a little research to see whether I could turn the fruit into jelly. Let the spontaneous jelly experiment begin!

For a couple of years, I’ve been experimenting with making jelly without adding commercial pectin, so it’s always a surprise. This one turned out very well and tastes fabulous. It’s a beautiful orange color and I can’t wait to try some on a breakfast roll.

To begin, peel the papaya and remove all the “caviar-looking” seeds. Cut the papaya into chunks. This recipe calls for 2 quarts of chunks papaya which is about two papayas or one very large papaya.

Note that these are Mexican papaya which are larger and less sweet than Hawaiian papaya. If you’re using Hawaiian papaya, you’ll need more of the fruits in order to get two quarts and you may want to reduce the sugar since they’re sweeter.

24Bite Recipe: Papaya Jelly Without Commercial Pectin

Be sure to use the juice and lime. These ingredients are important for your jelly to set. If you don’t have orange juice, try pineapple juice instead.

24Bite Recipe: Papaya Jelly Without Commercial Pectin

Always ensure that you’re using a deep pan when making jelly. It tends to foam up and you don’t want it to boil over onto your stove.

24Bite Recipe: Papaya Jelly Without Commercial Pectin

It’s boiling down nicely but there are still some chunks of papaya. The riper the papaya, the more easily it will break down for jelly.

24Bite Recipe: Papaya Jelly Without Commercial Pectin

We decided to go ahead and use the immersion blender to remove all the chunks but chunks aren’t a bad thing, either. Leave them, or not, whichever you prefer.

Making jelly never really made sense to me when I was reading about the spoon in the freezer and running your finger through it to see if it sets. Maybe if I had someone teaching me, I would understand it, but I just didn’t.

Once I learned that making jelly is scientific, it was so much easier! And, Christian definitely approved this method!

You just bring it to 220°F for jelly. This number changes when you’re not a sea level, so be sure to check your perfect recommended jelly temperature.

24Bite Recipe: Papaya Jelly Without Commercial Pectin

This recipe made about 50 ounces of delicious papaya jelly. Look at that color! So yummy!

At this point, you have jelly. You don’t need to do anything further to have jelly. You can put it in the refrigerator or freezer. We prefer shelf stable so we process it in the water bath canner. We don’t go through jelly quickly enough so shelf stable works much better. This jelly will last all year, until papaya comes into season again.

It’s really easy to preserve a batch of jelly but have a look at the instructions to make sure you’re preserving your jelly safely.

You will fill four 12-ounce jars, six 8-ounce jars or twelve 4-ounce jars. I had just a smidge leftover and I put that directly into the refrigerator for breakfast in the morning.

24Bite Recipe: Papaya Jelly Without Commercial Pectin (photo credit: mikhaild via 123RF)

Papaya Jelly Without Commercial Pectin

Bring a tropical taste to your next breakfast or brunch with this delicious, fruity papaya jelly
Prep Time10 mins
Cook Time45 mins
Total Time50 mins
Course: Condiment
Cuisine: American
Keyword: canning, jelly, papaya
Servings: 100 tablespoons
Calories: 37kcal
Author: Christian Guzman


  • 2 Large Papayas
  • 1/2 Cup Orange juice
  • 1 Lime juice and zest only
  • 4 Cups granulated sugar


  • Peel and remove seeds from papayas. Cut the fruit into chunks, enough for two quarts of chunked fruit. Discard fruit of lime after juicing and zesting.
  • Place all ingredients in a heavy-bottomed pan over medium heat. Place candy thermometer on side of pan to keep track of the temperature.
  • Bring mixture to a boil, stirring frequently. Continue to boil, still stirring frequently, until the mixture begins to thicken, about 25 minutes. Be sure to use a pan with high sides since jelly foams up at first and you don’t want it to boil over.
  • If the papaya doesn’t break down as much as you would like, use an immersion blender to remove any chunks.
  • Continue boiling, stirring frequently. Watch the thermometer. The jelly is ready when it reaches 220°F. Note that this is the sea level recommended temperature. Check the link above to determine the temperature when you’re above sea level.
  • At this point, you can cool the jelly then place in jars for the refrigerator or freezer. Or, if you prefer shelf stable, water bath as recommended.
  • Makes about four 12-ounce jars, six 8-ounce jars or twelve 4-ounce jars.

Follow 24Bite:

24Bite Logo: Cooking with Christian Guzman

Twitter | Facebook | Instagram | Pinterest

Pin It:

24Bite Recipe: Papaya Jelly Without Commercial Pectin
24Bite Recipe: Cooking with Christian Guzman Logo